mother holds her daughter in 2014 on a footbridge in Manila, Philippines. The Philippine president's executive order that the government begin distributing free contraceptives to the poor by 2018 may face delays because of a pending case before the country's Supreme Court. (CNS photo/Ritchie B. Tongo, EPA)

Duterte order that Philippines offer free contraceptives may face delays

713 0

 By Catholic News Service

MANILA, Philippines (CNS) — The Philippine president’s executive order that the government begin distributing free contraceptives to the poor by 2018 may face delays because of a pending case before the country’s Supreme Court.

In June 2015, the court placed a temporary restraining order on the contraceptives provision of a 2012 reproductive health law after a challenge called for certain implant contraceptives to be studied as potentially abortion-inducing. Those were taken off the government offerings. By August 2016, the list of contraceptives that had to be checked for possibly causing abortions was expanded.

Father Melvin Castro, chancellor of the Tarlac Diocese, called President Rodrigo Duterte’s executive order “premature.”

Father Castro, an outspoken critic of the law when it was still being vetted in Congress, told Catholic News Service, “I think some of our pro-life lawyers will question the executive order in the Supreme Court, precisely because there’s still a pending case in the Supreme Court.”

Duterte’s socio-economic secretary said Jan. 11 that the Philippines had to cut the poverty level to 14 or 13 percent from its current 21.6 percent by the end of Duterte’s term in 2022, and the executive order would “ensure zero unmet need for family planning” in the country whose 100 million people are more than 80 percent Catholic.

Multiple calls and text messages to the chairman of the Philippines bishops’ conference Commission on Family and Life went unanswered.

But Attorney Maria Concepcion Noche, president of the Alliance for the Family Foundation Philippines, said the executive order has no teeth.

“(It) did not overturn, nor did it override the temporary restraining order, so it does not have any effect on that,” Noche told CNS.

She said the emphasis of the president’s order is on contraception, which essentially whittles the entire reproductive health law down to a “population control” measure, without taking into account other aspects such as obstetric care, prenatal services, upgrading of medical facilities toward the service of the poor and other provisions.

The executive order “is not even about reproductive health,” she said.

Dr. Junice Melgar, head of Likhaan Center for Women’s Health, said the temporary restraining order has called for public hearings of the Philippines Food and Drug Administration, which she says is unprecedented and will further bog down any move toward distributing the contraceptives.

She told CNS, “In general … many of us in the reproductive health community are happy that the executive branch thinks there should be a strong enforcement of the law.”

Melgar pointed out the Duterte administration’s strongman approach to what he dubbed the country’s “drug problem.” Since Duterte came into office in June 2016 after running on a campaign to rid the country of criminals, about 6,200 people have died in both police anti-drug operations and from vigilante killings of alleged drug dealers and addicts. A majority of those killed come from the ranks of the country’s poorest, who mostly constitute Likhaan’s clientele.

“The executive hand is very strong in the Philippines at this point,” she said. “Even its drug campaign. It’s able to use force, actually, supposedly to end the drug problem in the Philippines. So I don’t know if it has the power as well to sort of negotiate with the Supreme Court.”

But Melgar called this a double-edged sword. She said without the free government contraceptives, her nongovernmental organization’s clinics are relying on contraception donations from the U.S. and other European countries, which all have been critical of the Philippine war on drugs and have threatened to withhold aid to the Philippines. She said even her group’s education campaign of going out to poor neighborhoods and teaching about contraception is being hampered because workers are too afraid to go to areas where people are being killed in the “war on drugs.”

During his six months in office, Duterte has alluded to possibly declaring martial law to better enforce his anti-drug campaign, and he has said several times in speeches he would have to change a provision that requires Supreme Court and Congressional consensus to do this, indicating a willingness to take on the nation’s high court.

“It would be great, that commitment from the executive branch, but of course we are worried, too,” said Melgar. “If it’s going to be family planning at the point of a gun, that will not be good.”

Related Post

The U.S. Department of Agriculture is seen in Washington March 18, 2012. The USDA is one of several federal agencies that will be affected by proposed rules announced Jan. 16, 2020, by President Donald Trump to ensure faith-based service providers and organizations are not discriminated against in agency regulations or their grant-making process because of religion. (CNS photo/Gary Cameron, Reuters)

Bishops welcome guidance on school prayer, Trump’s proposed rules

Posted by - January 26, 2020 0
WASHINGTON (CNS) — The chairmen of the U.S. bishops’ religious liberty and Catholic education committees Jan. 20 praised the Trump…
Denver Archbishop Samuel J. Aquila delivers the homily Jan. 6 during a Mass at the SEEK2019 conference at the Indiana Convention Center in Indianapolis. The Fellowship of Catholic University Students sponsor the biennial conference which drew 17,000 mainly college students this year. Archbishop Aquila took a brief break from the retreat taking place for bishops in the U.S. at Mundelein Seminary at the University of St. Mary of the Lake near Chicago to celebrate the Mass at the conference. (CNS photo/Sean Gallagher, The Criterion)

Keep bringing Christ to others, archbishop tells SEEK conference

Posted by - January 12, 2019 0
INDIANAPOLIS (CNS) — Denver Archbishop Samuel J. Aquila described the 17,000 mostly college students attending SEEK2019 in Indianapolis as “a…
In his ministry as archbishop of Manila, Philippines, and in his travels for Caritas Internationalis, Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle said he is reminded of the true meaning of hope by people living in situations the world would see as hopeless. Cardinal Tagle is pictured speaking to World Youth Day pilgrims in 2016 in Krakow, Poland. (CNS photo/Bob Roller)

Gospel message of hope often is taught by the poor, cardinal says

Posted by - January 6, 2018 0
VATICAN CITY (CNS) — In his ministry as archbishop of Manila and in his travels for Caritas Internationalis, Cardinal Luis…
SOFIA, Bulgaria (CNS) -- God is love, but too many Christians live their faith in a way that undermines any attempt to communicate that essential fact to others, Pope Francis said. Celebrating a late afternoon Mass May 5 in Sofia's Battenberg Square, the pope wore over his chasuble a gold-embroidered, Byzantine-style stole given to him that morning by Prime Minister Boyko Borissov. The pope's homily focused on the day's Gospel reading about the disciples' miraculous catch of fish after the risen Jesus told them to try again even though they had caught nothing all night. After the resurrection, the pope noted, "Peter goes back to his former life" as a fisherman and the other disciples go with him. "The weight of suffering, disappointment and of betrayal had become like a stone blocking the hearts of the disciples," he said. "They were still burdened with pain and guilt, and the good news of the Resurrection had not taken root in their hearts." When things don't go the way people plan and hope, the pope said, it is natural for them to wish things could go back to the way they were and to just give up on hoping for something new and powerful. "This is the 'tomb psychology' that tinges everything with dejection and leads us to indulge in a soothing sense of self-pity," Pope Francis said. But the resurrection of Jesus makes clear that a "tomb psychology" is not compatible with a Christian outlook. However, the pope said, even when Peter seems about to give up, Jesus comes to him, calls him again and reconfirms his mission. "The Lord does not wait for perfect situations or frames of mind; he creates them," Pope Francis told the estimated 7,000 people gathered for the Mass. Jesus "does not expect to encounter people without problems, disappointments, sins or limitations," but he encourages and loves and calls people to start over again. "God calls and God surprises because God loves," he said. "Love is his language." Christians draw strength from knowing God loves them and that love must motivate them to love others as they try to share the Christian message, the pope said. With papal trips always described as visits to confirm Catholics in the faith, Pope Francis used his homily to encourage Bulgaria's 68,000 Catholics -- just 1 percent of the population -- to acknowledge the wonders God has done for them and to set out again on mission, "knowing that, whether we succeed or fail, he will always be there to keep telling us to cast our nets." Thirty years after the fall of communism and the breakup of the Soviet bloc, the pope called Bulgarian Catholics to a "revolution of charity and service, capable of resisting the pathologies of consumerism and superficial individualism," and instead sharing the love of Christ.

Christians’ first mission is to witness that God is love, pope says

Posted by - May 12, 2019 0
SOFIA, Bulgaria (CNS) — God is love, but too many Christians live their faith in a way that undermines any…